Make a Payment Allied Phone: 1-800-282-1446 Make a Payment Donegal Phone: 800-877-0600 Make a Payment EMC Phone: 855-404-9076 Make a Payment Erie Insurance Phone: 1-800-458-0811 ext. 2606 Make a Payment ESIP Phone: 607-756-4970 Make a Payment Farmers of Marble, PA Phone: 814-354-7315 Make a Payment Harleysville Phone: 1-866-665-4992 Make a Payment Merchants Phone: 1-800-462-8182 Make a Payment National General Phone: 1-800-325-1190 Make a Payment Penn National Phone: 800-766-2245 Make a Payment Progressive Insurance Phone: 1-800-776-4737 Make a Payment Safeco Phone: 888-723-3260 Make a Payment Selective Phone: 888-974-7400 Make a Payment State Auto Phone: 1-800-444-9950 Make a Payment Tuscarora Wayne Phone: 570-746-1515 Make a Payment VFIS Phone: 800-461-8347 Make a Payment
